My genuine advice is
a) you really shouldn’t take the LSAT after you’ve only taken 4 practice tests, but you can’t postpone your test date now so this is a moot point. No use in pulling a no-show, so you might as well take the test and see how you do.
b) this kind of question is usually pointless until you come back with an actual score. Like someone else pointed out, 154-163 is a wide range…come back with a 154 and most people will quite rudely tell you not go to law school at all or implore you to take 6-12 months to study and retake. Come back with a 163 and people will be more optimistic about your chances (while still imploring you to take 6-12 months to study and retake).
I made the mistake of rushing into my first LSAT without any practicing too (I had only looked at one practice test, and I don’t think I timed myself). I made a 160 the first time, in October 2010; I took it again this October and made a 167. Even though I’m unfortunately still going to be applying later than I would like, my possible options now are absolutely different with that 7-point jump. I may attempt a higher score in February in case I get waitlisted; just another 3-point jump could make another big difference for me.
So based on my own positive experience with waiting and retaking, I would really urge you to not apply this year…take more time, study for February or June, and apply early next cycle. There was an obvious trend upward with the first three PTs. That is proof of your ability to improve greatly upon your initial score and probably fairly quickly. You also have an advantage that I don’t, youth. I’m 30, so I was antsy as it was about delaying applications for one year. I really don’t have intentions of putting them off again. But you haven’t even graduated yet. You can take that year off to go abroad again, do more interning, find a job…whatever you find enjoyable and productive and that can fill a line on your resume or inspire a great PS.
When you say your study-abroad grades “do not count” toward your GPA, are you saying those courses didn’t have grades at all, or just that your undergrad program doesn’t calculate them into your GPA? I ask because LSAC counts ALL undergraduate work. So even if your undergrad won’t count them, if those grades are on your transcript or otherwise documented somewhere then LSAC will recalculate your GPA to include those classes, and the LSAC GPA is the one law schools will use.
At the moment though I’ll assume your LSAC GPA will also be a 3.0, which as you know isn’t considered high. You didn’t mention it so I’ll also assume you’re not a URM, but if you are that also changes how you should view your potential. Regardless, you’ll have to view yourself as a potential splitter, and for that reason I don’t recommend you look at LSP; it’s not usually a great predictor for splitters or URMs. But LSN is a good site to look at. I looked at the three schools you mentioned for the last two admissions cycles and this is what I found for people around your GPA (3.0-3.2 range):
- Denver: 160 looks like the golden number. 157-159 seemed split between admits and waitlisted people for people with a 3.0 and above.
- George Mason: you need a 164 to have a good chance at being admitted, though there were several waitlisted people in this range as well.
- College of William & Mary: you need a 165-166 to even have a glimmer of hope, but the odds are much more likely that you will be waitlisted. Doesn’t seem to be very splitter-friendly unless you are a URM.
Note: I didn’t go through any profiles to see how many of the waitlisted people got admitted from that. Also keep in mind that the later you apply the more likely you are to get waitlisted or denied (another reason to retake/wait until early next cycle to apply).