Advice for a third time failure

So I’ll say this up front – I already feel awful and I’m not really interested in negative comments or comments about my intelligence or ability to be a lawyer. Please only respond if you’re willing to be understanding and helpful.

That aside, I have now failed the IL bar 3 times. I’m numb and don’t really know what to think or what to do now. Friends and family are pretty insistent upon me taking it again, a fourth time, because they believe I’ll never be happy unless I pass (probably true). But I’m not sure I have the capacity to spend another 2-3 months studying and then walk into the test knowing what has happened every other time I’ve taken it.

So here’s my dilemma:
-Do I take IL again?
-Do I take UBE in a state with a lower score requirement and then hope IL will eventually come around to the UBE and waive in?
-Do I call it quits?

I have a job that doesn’t require the bar, but I’d REALLY like to explore other avenues that may require a bar. I’m still waiting on my score report but I’d guess that, once again, the MBE fucked me. I felt slightly more confident about it, though I ran out of time on both AM and PM and had to fill in approx 5-10 random answers. This has happened to me every bar exam and I don’t know how to fix it (people saying you finished with 30-60 minutes… TELL ME YOUR SECRETS)

Any/all advice is appreciated. I’m feeling pretty miserable. I know I’m a capable and intelligent person…it just isn’t translating into this standardized test.

I understand this is difficult and you are probably very upset, distraught, and feel defeated, but you have to keep your chin up. It is alright, and perfectly normal to feel the way you do, but give yourself a little time to feel like this and then get back to the grind.

As far as taking a UBE state’s exam, that is certainly a possibility. Would you be willing to relocate? Can you take the test in a neighboring JX and just sit tight at your current job for some time?

People fail this exam every year. People also fail this exam multiple times. You can pass and you will, it has just taken you longer than you imagined or planned.

I wouldn’t get too discouraged and keep fighting. You know your study plan and habits and what works best for you better than I do. Look into ways to revamp your study plan or material.

The true test of the professional is to get back in the saddle and ride again when they have just been faced with results that are not favorable.

In order to get some pertinent advice, can you tell us how you prepared for the exam in general and specifically the MBE? How many questions did you do, what was your method of review etc.

I finished both NY and CA with time to spare by just having supreme confidence in my answer choice, regardless. Take the time to read the question, but once you pick an answer mark it, forget the question ever existed, and move on. You lose a ton of time by going back and forth only to settle on the choice you initially picked, or struggling between two incorrect answer choices where it doesn’t matter at all which you pick.

How was your mental state on the actual exam? That plays a huge role as well. Were you comfortable or did you feel like the world was falling down around you as you took the exam? As hard as it is, you really need to relax when you’re taking the exam. Easier said than done, I know, but you can pick up a ton of points simply by being relaxed and having some confidence in yourself when you’re actually taking the exam.

Best of luck.

What were your MBE scores for those three times you took the exam?

How far off were you?

What bar materials did you use?

Just passed IL.

First, let me say I wouldn’t wish what happened to you on my worst enemy and I’m super impressed that you’re able to keep getting back on the horse and studying. It says a lot about your tenacity and dedication.

Now for my advice, I’m convinced that the only way to pass the MBE (and to a lesser extent the essays) is to know the law down cold. When I took the simulated MBE I got a score that was well within the failing range for IL. I realized that following a bar prep course to a T would mean I was likely to fail, so I consulted my friends. One of my friends suggested I make my own flash cards with questions regarding rules of law and the rule of law on the back. In the three weeks before the bar, I made close to 1000 flash cards with the entire convisor outline MBE material and most essay stuff on them. Those flash cards were glued to the hip, if I was at the gym, the bar, at a friends house, etc. Those cards were with me. My practice MBE scores shot through the roof, from 40-50% right to 80% right or better. It also gave me a foundation for the essays. Also I read every Barbri model answer for the essays, didn’t outline them, definitely didn’t write them out, but made more flash cards of the scenarios the essays presented and barbri’s model answer to the problem. Come the actual bar, I felt decent on the essays. For the MBE I was still blindsided, like everyone always is, but I started eliminating answers I knew were wrong and giving it my best guess. It seemed to work out in the end.

+1 on the essay prep. I failed last year ¶ in July, and will know if I pass hopefully this week as I retook the 2nd time this past July so my advice won’t be proven decent until I get results; however, reading those Barbri sample answers to the past published essay questions were a God-send. Not the “examiner analysis” that quotes cases (because… really?) but the Barbri model passing answer. I ripped out those pages and highlighted them to death. I felt so good on the essays as a result. I don’t think Barbri assigns you all of the essays in that book, but I made sure I ready every single one of them and the answer.

As for the MBE, that has been my struggling point. That’s why I didn’t pass last year. This summer I took every single MBE question Barbri provides you, whether it be actually MBE questions, MPQs, etc. and made sure I wrote out ALL my wrong answers… It remains to be seen if my strategy worked; however, I felt much better this go around than I did last year.

However, I may be turning to this thread for solace if I don’t pass again… :laughing:

Keep in mind - the most successful people are not the ones that are good test takers. Successful people overcome hurdles, and what makes them successful is that they continue to pick themselves up and move forward. How you perform on some out-dated, overrated, overpriced exam does not correlate whatsoever to your ultimate happiness and success. Heck, my richest friends were told they would never amount to anything, repeatedly, and let that fuel their fire. I also know a lot of broke lawyers who got straight As and are waiting tables because their law firm jobs aren’t cutting it. So hang in there and know that what is meant to happen will happen!

Missed by 7 points this time. Once I knew I failed, I knew it would be by a larger margin.

I self studied because I honestly couldn’t afford a bar prep company and was so broke that I couldn’t find a spare $350 for Adaptibar.

My studying essentially went as follows: review Barbri’s CMR for each MBE topic. Make my own outlines based on that. Do Kaplan MBE questions to practice.

Didn’t practice the essays until the very end of my prep, which probably screwed me this time around. Previously I scored very high on the essays, this time around I was average or below on every essay.

Appreciate the advice. I did find myself going back to a lot of questions after narrowing it down. However, I felt mostly calm during the exam, even surprised myself and gained confidence when topics showed up that I knew immediately. That being said, timing ended up being an issue toward the end, and I guessed on at least 50% of property questions.

How many Kaplan questions did you do this time around? Any idea what your accuracy rate was? I would seriously advocate for adaptibar…

Also just passed IL.

Let me just echo the others to begin. I’m sorry you didn’t pass but man kudos on your resolve. Also, don’t give up on the bar just yet.

I hesitate to tell you a “best” way to study. My study method was different than virtually all of my LS friends that took the bar. Here’s what I mean by different. We all took the same prep course, but our methods varied. Some wrote outlines. Some wrote flash cards. I used adaptibar and bought the critical pass MBE flashcards. I barely touched the critical pass flash cards. I listened to the barbri lectures and filled in the outlines to the lectures as well. I also did a ton of adaptibar mbe questions. In hindsight, the critical pass flash cards were a stupid purchase on my part. I never used flash cards in undergrad or law school, and shouldn’t have tried to start using them for the bar. I’m an audible learner. I retain more from listening to a lecture than I do from reading an outline. The reason I say all of this is because I would hesitate to try doing what someone else has done just because he/she passed the bar. Also, for what it’s worth, I very rarely ever touched my conviser mini review or the full outlines Barbri gives you.

Were I in your shoes, I would reevaluate my own study habits. Are you studying efficiently? I’m operating on a lot of assumptions here but typically time management issues can be mitigated by preparation. Did you practice MBE Q’s under timed conditions? I found this very helpful for not only answering MBE questions but giving me a feel for how quickly I needed to move. I really can’t point to one specific thing that I think helped me to pass I just put a shit load of time in. I wrote practice essays and did a ton of MBE questions. I did both under timed conditions once I became comfortable with my level of knowledge in the various areas of law.

I hope that there something above that will help you to approach your preparation in a way that allows you to be successful in the future. I definitely would not give up. You obviously have put a ton of time/money/effort into this endeavor already. I wish you all the best and will be happy to help in any way that I can moving forward if you have any questions.

I’m right there with you. I just want you to know we are not going through this alone. I agree with the fact that it dwindles down to our study habits and what works best for us. I continued to listen to classmates and what they were doing and it worked for them, yet not for me. The first time I took it I did literally every single assignment Barbri offered. Worst decision ever. We will overcome this. The fact that we are not giving up says a lot about our character and determination. We will be licensed lawyers. And we will be amazing at our jobs I guarantee it.

Advice can be a bit tough without knowing the specifics as to how you studied for prior attempts at the exam, but having taught the MBE for some time now one commonality I do notice among almost all students is not spending enough time working on understanding the logic (or lack thereof) of the incorrect answer choices, and in general not spending enough time on test-taking strategies. There is a ton of law to stuff into our head for the test so most of our time is spent memorizing the law but a balance is needed in which the content is learned but an understanding of the test is also gained.

My advice would be as you continue to work through practice questions to focus as much on the “distractors” (the wrong answer choices) as you do on the correct answer. Ask yourself “what is it about this answer that made it wrong?” It seems to me that the writers of the test have sort of an algorithm for creating distractors and the better you get at recognizing how they go about creating these wrong answers that seem quite correct the better you will get at spotting them.

To be clear, the MBE requires a strong foundation of knowledge. But I’ve worked with so many students who know the law well and don’t succeed on the exam. So there is an element to this test that goes beyond legal knowledge for sure.

–Sean

I also failed three times in PA with Barbri and studied the same way all three times.

Figured I needed to make some drastic changes for my fourth try. Ended up using THEMIS and writing the exam with my hands. However, I didn’t really change much with regards to studying habit. My weakness was also the MBE and I barely scored enough to pass on my fourth try. But it felt good.

OP probably didn’t study hard enough meaning he probably did not even complete a bar prep course or complete 1,000 MBE practice questions, which is kind of like the minimum on TLS.

That really should be the bare minimum for practice questions. If you start 90 days before the test, that’s like an average of 11 practice questions a day. You’re talking about a 20 minute per day commitment. I did 2700+ questions and a full bar prep course while working full time.

Re-read Op’s post, here’s my advice:

The MBE is a learnable test. Buy adaptibar and Kaplan’s MBE Qbank. Do all of the practice questions. Read the explanations. If you do this, you will have seen 80-90% of the MBE and you’ll know the right answer vs. the trap answers immediately on the real thing. Or at least you will have a real instinct for the test.

As far as timing, I learned on my first shot at the LSAT that the worst thing is to fall behind on time. Since then I have operated on every exam under this guiding principle: you are not allowed to have a time issue on the exam. Avoid that at all costs. That is how I treated every section of the bar, including the essays. I spent exactly one hour on each of the essays in Florida (you get three hours for three essays). If I wasn’t done writing my essay when an hour was up, too bad. I moved on. On the MBE you get a little less than two minutes per question. My strategy was to give myself about twenty seconds less than the allotted time on each question. Speed is the key. You take the minute and half per question to do your best to figure out the best answer. Once a minute and a half is done, you’re done with the question so pick an answer and move on. Use that strategy and you won’t have a time issue.

It sounds like you’re spending time negotiating with answer choices - and based on your results it sounds like the time wasting isn’t helping you figure out the right answer. Don’t negotiate. Do your best to find a “best” answer choice in an extremely limited amount of time, and I bet you’ll get a higher percentage correct and you’ll actually have answered every question after a fair evaluation instead of running out of time.

That was my strategy, passed the MBE the first time in July 2016 with a 167 scaled.

EDIT to add: I see that you self-studied. There is no self-study for this exam. You need to find a way to get your hands on Kaplan or Themis and Adaptibar. It’s a cost of doing business, and failure is far more expensive. Get adaptibar at the discounted rate and then persuade a lot of people to use your coupon code and get money back. Go to Themis and ask what it would take to be a rep and get a free course, or failing that, what’s their bottom dollar on it. Make it happen.

Excellent advice.

Lots of people above have given good advice. I’d like to add that the way I handled the MBE was by treating every question as a process of elimination. It is extremely rare that the answer you would write on an essay test will appear in the choices. If it did, the question would be too easy. So read each prompt, come up with what you think the answer should be (if you can quickly) and then go to the answer choices. If the right one doesn’t pop out at you, go one by one and see what you can eliminate. Even if you don’t know the exact law on point re: the actual question, you can eliminate lots of answer choices just by knowing the law relevant to those choices (e.g., you know that the exception tested in answer choice (a) is wrong, so even if you don’t know what the actual question is looking for, you can eliminate answer choice (a)).

Also, I used the app Flashcard Hero to make my own cards during the last couple of weeks. I find making my own flash cards helps memorization, but writing by hand takes too long. With the app, you can type and it goes a lot faster.

All this said, I don’t know my actual scores because I passed IL and they don’t give us our reports. But I scored well on the Barbri midterm (95+ percentile), so I would recommend trying out this technique if you haven’t already.