“Is it possible to define the meaning of “unfair surprise” and “oppression” more precisely so as to rebut those scholars who argue that unconscionability is an ambiguous and ill-defined invitation to judicial intervention in private contracts?”
The author is questioning whether, by limiting the scope of “unfair surprise” and “oppression,” we could satisfy people who think those concepts give courts too much power over contracts between private parties.
In other words, “Is there a definition out there that doesn’t make the terms “unfair surprise” and “oppression” sound like ambiguous bs designed to trigger what are mostly meritless, bs claims?”
The answer is…“No!” Judges know it when they see it; that’s the standard.