Where should I go?
- NYU at $220k
- UVA at $170k
- Michigan at $150k
- Columbia at $240k
- Berkeley at $160k
Updating this because I just heard back from Berkeley with a better grant. I’m interested to see how it changes people’s views.
My SO and I work in NYC right now, but my SO is from the LA area, and I want to end up there after graduation. My SO would move with me if I chose a school outside NYC (she works in an industry with lots of jobs near universities), but it would obviously be easier not to have to relocate.
My immediate goal after graduation is a federal district court clerkship, and I see myself practicing some flavor of public interest civil litigation at a non-profit or in government, but I’ve also thought about plaintiffs’-side firms, maybe in civil rights or employment.
I have a 3.67/174 with work experience and don’t want to retake (my score is old and I’d have to start from scratch). The two options I’m considering most seriously are:
Berkeley ($105k grant, $160k CoA): This is the obvious choice right now, since nowhere else has a better network of alums working public interest in CA. I haven’t visited, but will be flying out this week. I only have two serious reasons to choose NYU over Berkeley. First, Berkeley’s LRAP isn’t as strong as NYU’s, but since there’s a chance I’ll be in private practice at some point, the lower cost probably offsets that. Second, I worry about whether a degree from Berkeley is less portable if I end up outside of CA in the future.
I have a few other less serious concerns about Berkeley. Relocation will be costly and may involve some loss of income while my SO looks for a new job, although probably nowhere near the extra cost of attending NYU. Also, I’ve heard some complaints about the administration and wonder how much support I’ll get during the job search and clerkship process. Finally, as a somewhat uptight and relatively moderate white heterosexual male liberal, I wonder whether the culture will be the right fit for me. But all of these things seem insubstantial compared to the placement advantage and reasonable cost.
NYU ($90k grant, $220k CoA): Great PI network and best LRAP program besides Columbia’s. Even though I’ve been in the NYC area for a while, the Village would be an awesome place to be. But the higher cost of attendance would be an issue if I ended up working at small to mid-sized firm, and finding a job in LA would be easier from Berkeley. Conversely, if ever work outside of CA, a degree from NYU might carry more weight.
The options that I’m not really seriously considering anymore are:
Michigan: ($120k grant, $150k CoA): This is still the cheapest option, but not by much. I haven’t visited. Berkeley has better LRAP, a placement advantage in the area and region I’m interested in, better weather, and the opportunities that come with proximity to a large city.
UVA ($105k grant, $170k CoA): I love Charlottesville and am very impressed with UVA’s clerkships stats. I know that Berkeley and NYU will say people self-select out of clerkships or clerk after working, but I also think that part of the explanation must be that UVA is better at placing people in clerkships outside NY/CA. The amount of support that UVA provides for public interest was also pleasantly surprising. Still, the PI community is pretty small, and I worry about not being able to finding a network of students/alums in the area I end up in. Also, UVA is now more expensive than Berkeley.
Columbia ($75k grant, $240k CoA): The considerations in favor of Columbia are lay prestige, a more livable neighborhood compared to NYU, and a slightly better LRAP program (no loan payments below $100k). However, Columbia’s biglaw and clerkship outcomes seem to be equivalent to NYU (NYU even seems to have a slight advantage in clerkships), and it has a much smaller PI community, and fewer litigation-based clinics and black letter or practice-oriented classes. All that plus the extra $20k in debt seems to be enough to rule it out for me.
I’ve shown Michigan’s grant to Columbia, NYU, UVA, and Berkeley. NYU and UVA declined to increase their grants, Berkeley increased their grant to the amount above, and Columbia hasn’t responded.
In case anyone suggests any options not on this list, I was waitlisted at Harvard and am waiting to hear back from Yale and Stanford, but assume that I will be rejected or waitlisted there too. I applied across the T14 plus UCLA and USC, but the best grant I got is a match from Georgetown.