Doing a bit of work from home today. Originally came to see what you kids were talking about these days, but saw so much misinformation re: DC firms that I thought I’d take questions for a bit.
For starters, Hogan and A&P are perfectly fine firms and solidly within the top tier in DC. I don’t work for either but know people at both.
I think the biggest thing you could help with is talk about the realistic grade expectations of DC firms, and also what sorts of softs/WE are actually impressive to you. Lots of people with some Hill experience seem to think they have DC in the bag, but I am skeptical.
At my firm (generally among the most selective), grades are very important, but not the only consideration. Grades will get you in the door but will not get you an offer. Once you’ve made the cut, softs play a large role, particularly your interviews. Interviewers are looking for people with whom they might actually want to have an extended conversation. It also helps to have a clear reason for wanting to work at the firm. I don’t particularly care about Hill experience over other types of jobs. There are some very interesting people in the t14 (where I interview) who have done very interesting things; Hill experience is among the less interesting. (Though if the Hill experience put you in touch with an influential partner, that could be to your advantage.)
More? I suppose that depends on which firms you’re talking about. Journal certainly helps.
One of the reasons I want to work at a DC firm (and this holds true for all of the DC firms I bid on) is that they offer an opportunity to work on issues relating to the federal government and regulatory affairs, which is rare or nonexistent in other markets. However, I am a little worried about expressing so much enthusiasm for this aspect of DC practice that the interviewer thinks I will jump ship for a government job at the earliest opportunity. What is your experience what this phenomenon? Am I overthinking it?
This isn’t really a DC specific question, but I’ll ask since you do OCIs: if a person with far below median grades gets preselected to interview with you, is it safe to assume that the firm is willing to look past the grades if the interview goes well?
I think it’s fine to express an interest in regulatory work at a firm that has a strong regulatory practice. However, I would also mention some of the other work that the firm does. I think the worry would be less about your jumping ship and more about whether you’d be the right fit the group, and if not, the firm (does the regulatory group utilize summers? You’re only a 2L, so how do you know that you will actually like regulatory work in practice rather than in theory? What will you do if you don’t like reg work or the reg group doesn’t like you?). Better to express an interest in regulatory work but openness to other areas than to exhibit a myopic focus on regulatory work (this goes for most practice areas except for “litigation” and “corporate” in broad strokes).
If the interview goes so well that the interviewer is willing to fight for you in the hiring committee meeting, yes. But the odds will not be in your favor if the firm normally selects students with top grades. Good softs will also help.
Vandy/Texas student with top 20% grades and LR here. What firms will give me a solid look? I’ve interned for more than 1 federal agency and a couple of DC-based non-profits/lobby groups.
This may not be a question for you but I’ll ask it anyway. If you name someone as an alternate does it make sense for them to send a resume and cover letter (mass mail) to your recruiter?
Logic being that grades and resume were of interest to your firm so might make sense to try backdoor method,
Along those lines, what’s your general impression of a student who’s sure he wants to litigate, but is unsure of a specific practice area? I have 2 or 3 that interest me, but just am not prepared to commit to that degree…
Depends on the firm. If you’re interviewing with Hogan, either is fine. If you’re interviewing with W&C, saying you’re open to corporate will probably get you dinged.
You’re a 2L. No one really expects you to know what you want (90% of you will probably say “appellate litigation”). Saying you’re generally interested in lit, with a few areas that seem interesting in particular, is fine (provided the firm does work in those areas).