Duke Vs. Cornell

If called off Duke’s WL…would it be worth it to switch from Cornell to Duke with only days left before classes?

nope

If NYC biglaw, no.

If mostly anything else, maybe. What do you want to do?

Any scholarship info?

If you really want to, sure. Though it is a couple of spots up in the rankings, it is a peer school, so there would be little advantage (esp. if you want to work in the Northeast). It is unlikely to really help or hurt you in any way.

Corporate law…not necessarily in NYC

doesn’t seem to be worth the hassle. where it might make sense is if you want to target a southern market (and have ties, of course).

Cornell is great for NYC and ok for the rest of the Northeast. You probably won’t get to Chicago/LA without ties to the region.

Duke has a bit wider of a pull outside of the Northeast, especially in the south.

Where do you want to work, ideally?

If you don’t give a fuck, go to Cornell and aim for NYC, especially if you have a scholarship.

I’d go Duke if it were me. Mostly because I like the school more, better weather, and I know a shitton of graduates who were happy with their experience, as well as the jobs they got afterward.

I’d say Duke for the weather alone. I can’t think of many other places I’d rather not be than rural New York in January.

Are you already in Ithaca? If so, I think leaving would be a poor choice. Extra hassle, extra cost of moving again, and moving in and getting ready to start 1L would be pretty hectic IMO with LARW starting next week and then classes starting on the 20th.

The weather is awesome though down here. I wore a hoodie I think three times the entire year. Other than that, I wore a t-shirt and jeans to school pretty much every day (this is not recommended if you attend Cornell).

Not that bad. However, navigating the icy hills of Ithaca is not fun plus the wind makes Ithaca even more unusually bitter than many places in Western NY.

I think duke is unquestionably better in terms of placement outside NYC but maybe less so inside NYC. If you have any money at Cornell, I’d stay there though.

Need more info. Duke probably offers a better quality of life, better Southern placement &, maybe, more clerkship opportunities. Cornell is better for NYC placement, but the environment seems more stressful.

Why do you say Cornell is better for NYC placement? Will the same firms go deeper into Cornell’s class than Duke’s?

Yes.

Fixed.

Just because more students from Cornell go to NYC doesn’t mean firms will dip deeper in Cornell’s class. That’s got a lot to do with self-selection and Cornell’s relative disadvantage at placing outside the Northeast.

Define “dip deeper”, then. If at a given firm there are more students from Cornell than from Duke, and those students are ranked lower in their class than the Duke students, is that not “dip deeper”? That is the case at most large top NYC firms who do recruit from both schools. That may very well be due to the fact that many Duke students choose to go to DC or elsewhere, and most Cornell students self-select into NYC, but I don’t know how else you would define it.

Edit: This is naturally a generalization, as are all statements about schools’ and firms’ behavior. There are certainly NYC firms that do recruit more heavily from Duke but the above generalization is certainly true for my firm and seems to be true at at least a handful of other top firms, though I naturally don’t know the exact class rank of every person from Cornell and Duke who went to every firm in NYC.

To address OP’s question, I think that any benefit gained from choosing Duke at this late stage are in areas other than your chance of getting an offer at a large NYC firm. That doesn’t mean there aren’t benefits, or that those benefits aren’t potentially important, but I think it’s false to say being at Duke will get you offers from more firms or more prestigious NYC firms than the same rank at Cornell.

Edited for clarification.

My point is that just because more Cornell grads place in NYC firms than Duke grads, that doesn’t necessarily mean NYC firms prefer Cornell grads. Most associates and partners in the NYC firm I worked at considered them roughly equivalent. You have to remember that while Duke lacks a big home market and sends their grads everywhere, Cornell really only has NYC, so by definition more Cornell grads will target and end up there. The only tangible advantage I could see is that Cornell will have a stronger alumni presence in NYC.