So my school has this policy which seems to suggest grade appeals are only doable if it’s a procedural or clerical error. I am planning on going to the school to talk about this grade I got in my seminar class. It’s not an issue of how well I did on the paper because I did well on the final paper. It’s more about how the class ended up being graded. The class isn’t curved and it’s graded restrictly on a point system.
I just wanted some opinions on whether or not you guys think this can be appealed. So the syllabus mentions the grades at 75% based on the final paper and 25% for participation. I got a 88 on the final paper and received a B- in the class. I had myself documented as two absences, I emailed the Professor telling her I only had two absences and asking how that would affect my grade. She mentioned that one absence would not count towards my grade, and that the other absence would be proportionally distributed and therefore affect me very little. It turns out each absence dropped me one grade.
She ended up having 4 absences as the maximum amount that would affect our grade, each absence constituting 5% (this hardly seems proportional to me), any absences after 4 would not matter. The presentation only constituted for 5% (and this took weeks to prepare). I got full points for the presentation and a B+ on the paper but ended up with a B- because I had two absences counted against me.
The professor documented me with three absences, which I argued I only had two. She even gave everyone a opportunity after class to check the attendance sheet for the year and to make changes if there was mistakes, I did not look at the sheet and do that because I didn’t think it was important nor was I missing more than 2 classes. It seems that means attendance was almost based on a honor system of what we say it is. I emailed her in a email afterwards just to tell her I had two absences and confirm how important it was. She told me it wasn’t very important.
So I find out that apparently absences are huge and count a lot, and I dropped two grades because of the three absences I had (one absence is a freebie). I worked really hard in this class, I emailed the Professor about each absence (the two I had claimed to have, not the three) and did make up work for them. It just seems incredibly unfair that I would end up having two absences completely mess up my ranking. Do you think this matter can be appealed?
I basically want to argue I only had two absences, and since she allowed people to make changes to the attendance sheet I should be able to say I had 2 instead of three, because had I looked at the sheet I would make the change, granted it was my mistake in not doing so but it hardly seems fair that I should lose an entire grade because of it. Counting only 4 absences to make up the entire 20% hardly seems proportional which in my email to her she confirmed that attendance would be proportionally taken (total attendance is 13 classes). Not to mention people who would come in an hour late got to sign the sheet; it just seems so unfair.
Please give some reasonable insight on how I should approach this. I already talked to the Professor and she won’t change the grade. I plan on taking this matter up with the Academic dean. This negatively affects my chances at getting a good clerkship because it drops me from being in the top 5% to the top 10%
So she gave you the opportunity to correct the absence record and you did not do so, but now that grades are in you want to appeal something she gave you the opportunity to correct?
Yeah, I guess I don’t get it. You walk in with the sent date of the emails so you know the dates. If you’ve really only missed two, you defend it to the death and immediately correct the record when given the chance. That should have been the end of it.
Tough spot, but it seems you let it get to this point. Even if absences were 0.5% of the total grade, if I saw mine were wrong I correct the record (if the wrong number was more than the actual number…less I might let slide).
I just have to throw this out: presumably the 25% for participation required more than just showing up. Is there are possibility that the grade reductions were for your performance rather than merely your absences?
I was told pretty much why I got the B-, for having the two absences. She said she deducted 5% from my grade for each absence, I had a 91 which turned into a 81.
Okay. Just wanted to check. Honestly, I suspect an appeal wouldn’t get anywhere, because while I agree that 5% for each absence is a little much, presumably the prof applied the same requirement to everyone in the course, and it’s pretty much up to the professor’s discretion how they want to distribute the points for the required work. And as people have pointed out, you had the opportunity to check how many absences she had you down for. If you can absolutely document that one of the absences is wrong, you could try that. But I don’t think you’ll get anywhere challenging the prof’s decision to grade in a certain way.
It’s true I was given the opportunity in class to look at the attendance record and correct it; I didn’t do it because there was a small line after class and I had to do something (if memory serves me correctly), however, I was paranoid about how many absences I had (I never did check the record), the sign in sheet often gets passed around messily around the class and most of the time I have go up after class to sign in because I never got the sign in sheet, and I did send her a email telling her I had two absences (rather recklessly of me, I suppose asserting I had two absences in a email rather than going up and marking the record is completely different), I did ask her in the email how much two absences would count against me, and the way I was replied to, lead me to reasonably believe that each absence would affect me very little. I’m just very angry over the fact that each absence ended up marking me down one entire grade.
Just to be clear, 5% for every absence as soon as you’ve missed 2 (meaning the first one counts if you’ve missed 2 or more)? Or, first one’s free and 2, 3, 4, >5 = 5%, 10%, 15% and 20% gone?
I’m guessing the latter based on you’re explanation of 3 vs. 2 absences previously.
The first one is free, and subsequently each absence is a 5% mark down up to with a maximum deduction of 20%. It’s the only class where I had absences count for this much. If I was aware that each absence would mark me down one grade after the first, I would never miss a day of class even if I was coughing up my lungs…
The truth is that he should have checked it, but that doesn’t excuse her from getting it correctly the first time. It was her error. The fact that he did not check, even though he should have does not automatically excuse her of her mistake.
Not to mention is takes her 5-10 minutes to change the grade. Seriosly, you have to be a misrobale human being to do that to someone.
Lsomething is nagging me here. The maximum deduction for non-attendance is 20%, which would equate to 5 missed classes out of 13, or more than a third. Doesn’t the ABA require regular attendance? Wouldn’t that mean that if someone were documented to have missed mor than a third of their classes, they would not be allowed to get any credit for the class?
I know this is irrelevant to the OP, but this seems a bit screwy to me.
To the poster who says it only takes 5-10 minutes to change a grade, I’m pretty sure changing a grade after it has been submitted to the registrar is a lot more substantial than that.
Well most Professor I have that count attendance as part of the grade, which most do not, usually only has it affect 10% of the overall grade at most, assuming you miss all the classes but scored a perfect on the exam you can walk away with a A-. Not sure about the ABA thing, but I don’t think that is the case. Most of my professors don’t even keep attendance records. Perhaps the ABA does it based on a honor code thing.
I had my grades changed before. She has to file paperwork stating she miscalculated the grade (as in this case). Register will not reject the grade change. There is nothing to it.
ABA rule 403-D requires regular attendance, which has been interpreted to mean 80% (with generous rounding, that means a maximum of 3 absences out of 13 classes.
Apparently this rule is enforced with as much vigor as the quest for accurate employment statistics
She doesn’t want to do it because she has no way of knowing whether the OP is being honest or not. There was a time and place to make the change (and that procedure is there because she knows she might make a mistake, which is commendable on her part), and the OP did not take it. That’s the OPs fault. The OP can talk to her about it, but no procedure or agreement was violated, and if the OP loses his appeal (which he will), he should just suck it up and learn from it.