Help explain this Weaken-CE

This problem is under the Causal Reasoning section of PowerScore.

Stimulus: Violent crime in this town is becoming a serious problem. Compared to last year, local law enforcement agencies have responded to 17 percent more calls involving violent crimes, showing that the average citizen is more likely than ever to become a victim of a violent crime.

Stem: Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?


According to Powerscore, the causal reasoning is greater number of violent crimes–>more calls involving violent crimes. I’m told to attack the causal reasoning in the conclusion, only, but there is no causal reasoning in the conclusion (the average citizen is more victim than ever to become a victim of a violent crime).

How would you diagram this problem and aren’t you supposed to attack the conclusion and leave the premises alone in causal weakening?

I’ll bite. I think that it’s trying to say that the conclusion is stating that there have been more calls about violent crimes which they believe is caused by a rise in the number of violent crimes occurring.

So yes, the conditional chain would be that since there are a greater number of crimes → it must be the case that this is the reason for the greater number (percent) of calls involving violent crimes.

I believe a way to weaken this would be to find an alternate reason for the rise in calls, whatever that may be. Or by showing that the number of calls in total went down, which drove the percentage of, otherwise consistent, calls about violent crimes up. I’m sure there are other ways to weaken the answer choice, but you basically want to show that the evidence (the # of calls for violent crimes is going up) is flawed in some way, therefore the conclusion doesn’t completely follow and is weakened due to this additional knowledge about the evidence provided.

Thats just how I see it.

thanks for the response! I guess I’m supposed to extract the belief that underlies the conclusion

No problem.

I was actually having difficulty with CE weaken questions and found some advice, from another member (JEFFORT) who is on this forum but posted on another forum. I believe that this advice will help make things a little more clearer for what you need to do in these questions.


Wow, great find.

I wrote that two years ago.

OP: You should read the entire thread it is from. Myself and a few other veteran LSAT prep teachers fleshed out the topic in a lot of detail and my quoted post is just one part of it.

http://www.lsatdiscussion.com/index.php/topic,139.0.html

FYI: The conclusion is “Violent crime in this town is becoming a serious problem,” not “the average citizen is more likely than ever to become a victim of a violent crime.”