Hi. I’m a bit confused on this question especially with how the transitive property works here.
I diagrammed the stimulus as follows:
HS->WO and SM
WK->HS
SM->(NOT RC)
I understand I can put premise two on top of premise one.
So it would look like this.
WK->HS
HS->WO and SM
SM->(NOT RC)
Therefore: WK->(NOT RC)
My question is this: for premises two and three I see that the SM is in common however, I don’t understand how it connects because don’t you need both WO and SM to connect? Shouldn’t premise three be WO and SM->(NOT RC) for the connection to happen and not just the term SM? I apologize if this is a rather stupid question but it’s been bugging me.
No you don’t need WO as well as SM to get NOT RC. SM on its own is sufficient to trigger NOT RC, so whenever you have SM, which is what you get whenever you have HS, then you also trigger NOT RC in the process; the transitive property is perfectly applicable to this Q.
The transitive property is if A —> B and B —>C, then A —> C. Similarly,
(1) WK —> HS
(2) HS —> WO and SM
(3) SM —> NOT RC
Therefore WK → NOT RC
What’s troubling you is the WO but that term is inconsequential in this case because HS triggers BOTH WO and SM, and whenever SM is triggered then NOT RC is the result. Also, it might be more helpful if you mentioned what PT/question this is.
C must be true. The fact that they’re well-known means that they’re highly successful. The fact that they’re highly successful means that they’re self-motivated (along with being well-organized, although that doesn’t matter for this), and since they’re self-motivated, they don’t regret their career choice.
Yes, both C and D will have to be true for B to be true. The contrapositive of
B-> C AND D
is
NOT C OR NOT D → NOT B
So if either (or both) of C or D is missing/not true, then B can’t be true.
When you’re negating statements that have terms separated by AND or OR, the AND gets changed to OR, and vice-versa. I think it’s DeMorgan’s theorem, but don’t hold me to that. Here’s another example: