I’m just a 1L too, so I wouldn’t know how important they are. But I do know my writing instructor told us that her phone’s been ringing off the hook since we all gave her as a reference. So, they definitely are calling her.
Is it possible to give someone who knows you a bit better, like a writing instructor, as a reference?
I never really went to my writing instructors office hours last semester (I know stupid) but she is nice and would probably give me a reference. The problem is I have a career fair that I am attending tomorrow.
So email her today and ask if it’s okay to list her as a reference. She’s uniquely able to speak to your writing abilities, so even though you never went to her office hours, it doesn’t matter.