Retake a 173...?

**

Not an expert but from what I’ve seen, too high of a score can have an adverse effect on your cycle. Check out LSN and the applicant threads and you’ll see some 176s and such placed on WLs

ETA: that being said, your numbers looks solid for the schools you listed.

.

That GPA makes Chicago a long shot with any LSAT. A 175+ puts Columbia in play. NYU would probably take you with a 173. I don’t think any of those schools give much of a bump to ED applicants. I know it’s pretty much worthless at Columbia.