I know of the whole 12 point system. But it seems mathematically unlikely given Yale’s median and 75th percentiles that they can simply afford to admit as many splitters or even not-so-stellar scored candidates as has been implied. For them to admit 50% of 3.75+ and 175+ candidates, and an abysmal number of applicants in other brackets, I would bet statistics would say that the stronger end of the spectrum of the 3.75+ 175+ (just going to term this “elite”) crowd must have a large advantage.
Given the statistics from Yale’s ABA data:
https://officialguide.lsac.org/RELEASE/SchoolsABAData/SchoolPage/SchoolPage_Info/ABA_LawSchoolData.aspx
http://www.lsac.org/LSACResources/Data/lsats-administered.asp
First and foremost, since the median is 3.91 but the bottom quartile is 3.81, this means that the class holds twice as many students with over a 3.9 than those between 3.8 - 3.9. I do not think it is then a stretch to infer that students with 3.9+ have twice the chance as those with 3.8+ of getting in. If we apply this general pattern (okay big assumption but perfectly reasonable) to the “elite” crowd of 101/214 ~ .5 probability of being accepted:
x = probability of 3.8+ 175+ getting in
2x = probability of 3.9+ 175+ getting in
(2x + x)/3 = .5 (overall probability of getting in)
x = .333
2x = .666
So people with a 3.9+ and 175+ have a 2/3rds chance of getting in. Not bad if i do say so myself.
Even though half of the matriculating class at Yale (assuming % same for admitted - 137) has over the median of 3.9, a whole 230 admits out of 275 had over a 3.75. 85% of admits had over a 3.75, and the median for the school is 3.9. My math tells me that for those non-olympic-tier regular applicants riding on hard numbers over GPA 3.75+, at least 60% of that admitted population has over a 3.9. The theory isn’t really scientific, but its quite logical. Considering people with good numbers already have 1/2 odds of getting in off the bat, you can’t say YLS admission process still isn’t very numbers oriented. and given that twice as many people in the class have over a 3.9 than those that have a 3.8 (saying that 3.8+ students in general represent academically desired students, rather than interesting outliers with lower GPAs and amazing softs), it would be hard to argue that Yale doesn’t get excited by strong numbers in the application, including LSAT. If we can infer that Yale cares about strong numbers, than we can only imagine the odds of someone with a 3.9+ GPA and 177+ LSAT.
How many people with 3.9+ GPAs and 175+ LSATs could could have amazing softs anyway? I would figure WE, extracurricular, and community service should count, but thats far from writing a book/winning an olympic medal. Im hard pressed to believe that Yale Law is a black box. I would bet money its gamebable as every other law school is, the standards are simply higher. But nothing that cant be panned out for someone planning from year 1 of undergrad.
tl;dr People with strong numbers have a coin toss chance of getting in as it is, which is already phenomenal. If you dont buy into the Yale being above desiring people with strong scores, then its still easy to game the system and get a high GPA in an easy major, and study for a year to master the LSAT.